Hillsdale College Chargers All-MIFC Players
MIFC Offensive-Back of the Year: Scott Schulte, 1994
First Team
| Name | Position | Season |
| Sean Tierney | 1990 | |
| David Kendzicky | 1990 | |
| Mike Karpinski | 1992 | |
| Shannon Gregson | 1992 | |
| Scott Schulte | 1992 | |
| Mike Lang | 1992 | |
| Brett Myers | 1992 | |
| Mike Petrucci | 1992 | |
| Scott Schulte | RB | 1993 |
| Marty Walsh | DB | 1994 |
Second Team
| Name | Position | Season |
| Pete Gottick | 1990 | |
| Jon Palazzo | 1990 | |
| Jeff Cameron | 1990 | |
| Ken Carpenter | DL | 1994 |
| Scott Elwer | DB | 1994 |
| Greg Younger | QB | 1994 |
Honorable Mention
| Name | Position | Season |
| Scott Forst | 1990 | |
| Mark Vaselaney | 1990 | |
| Phil Getfield | 1992 | |
| Todd Glominski | 1992 | |
| Steve Quellhort | 1992 | |
| Robert Oginsky | Split-End | 1993 |
| Dave Ptacek | FB | 1994 |
| Matt Perl | OT | 1994 |
All-Academic
| Name | Position | Season | Team |
| Phil Getfield | 1992 | 1st Team | |
| Steve Quellhorst | 1992 | 1st Team | |
| Jerry Klekotka | 1992 | 1st Team | |
| Kurt Urban | 1992 | 1st Team | |
| Loren DeCarlo | 1992 | Honorable Mention | |
| Rob Pike | 1992 | Honorable Mention | |
| Dave Ptacek | 1992 | Honorable Mention | |