May 12, 2021
Hillsdale College Football
All-Great Midwest Athletic Conference Players
First Team
| Wyatt Batdorff | DB | 2017, 2018 |
| Trey Brock | WR | 2017, 2018 |
| Jake Bull | OL | 2017 |
| Danny Drummond | OL | 2017 |
| Jordon Harlamert | DL | 2017 |
| Nate Jones | LB | 2017 |
| Zach VanValkenburg | DL | 2017,2018 |
| John Brennan | TE | 2018 |
| Drew Callahan | OL | 2018 |
| Mark Konkle | OL | 2018, 2019 |
| Joe Philipp | K | 2018 |
| Jay Rose | LB | 2018 |
| Chance Stewart | QB | 2018 |
| David Graham | RB | 2019 |
| Zach Herzog | DB | 2019, S2021, F2021 |
| Bryce Sealock | K | 2019 |
| Drake Temple | DB | 2019 |
| Cole Johnson | OL | S2021, F2021 |
| Nate Chambers | DL | S2021, F2021 |
| Alex Anschutz | LB | F2021 |
| Isaac TeSlaa | WR | 2022 |
| Michael Herzog | RB | 2022, 2023 |
| Kyle Kudla | LB | 2022 |
| Luke Keller | P | 2022 |
| Nick Affholter | OL | 2023 |
| Riley Tolsma | DL | 2023 |
Second Team
| David Graham | RB | 2017, 2018 |
| Spencer Nehls | DB | 2017 |
| Zach VanOrman | OL | 2017 |
| Nate Jones | LB | 2018, 2019 |
| Jason McDonough | DB | 2018, 2019 |
| Drake Temple | DB | 2018 |
| Mitchell Albert | OL | 2019 |
| Alex Anschutz | LB | 2019, S2021 |
| Luke Keller | P | 2019 |
| Konnor Maloney | WR | 2019 |
| Jack McCarthy | OL | S2021, F2021 |
| Hunter Pearson | OL | S2021 |
| Jack Shannon | P | S2021, F2021 |
| Isaac TeSlaa | WR | F2021 |
| Michael Harding | TE | 2022 |
| Eli Haidamous | OL | 2023 |
| Ben Geno | OL | 2023 |
| Sam Lee | WR | 2023 |
Third Team
| Michael Harding | TE | S2021, F2021 |
| Kyle Parran | DL | S2021, F2021 |
| Kyle Kudla | LB | S2021 |
| Joe Royer | DL | S2021 |
| Jackson Gillock | DB | F2021 |
| Julian Lee | K | F2021 |
| Nick Affholter | OL | 2022 |
| Kendall Tobin | DL | 2022 |
Honorable Mention
| Jason McDonough | DB | 2017 |
| Timmy Mills | WR | 2017 |
| Joe Philipp | K | 2017 |
| Casey Schukow | DL | 2017 |
| Dan Shanley | DL | 2017, 2019 |
| Chance Stewart | QB | 2017 |
| Mitchell Albert | OL | 2018 |
| Merrick Canada | DB | 2018 |
| Nate Canterbury | DL | 2018, 2019 |
| Konnor Maloney | WR | 2018 |
| Joe Royer | DL | 2018, 2019 |
| Jack Shannon | P | 2018 |
| Nate Chambers | DL | 2019 |
| Cole Johnson | OL | 2019 |
| Martin Petersen | TE | 2019 |